new plymouth
Welcome to New Plymouth

New Plymouth is located in Payette County, Idaho. It was incorporated on February 15, 1896, and was the first planned community west of the Mississippi. The community was the combined project of a group of people supposedly dissatisfied with city life in Chicago, who formed what they called "The Plymouth Society of Chicago" in 1895. William E. Smythe, was a key founder and the chairman of the executive committee of the National Irrigation Congress and a famous irrigation promoter. Mr. Smythe was determined to found a colony to serve as a striking argument in favor of his project: irrigation. He spoke throughout the east, urging young and old men to go west in colonies and develop the country with the help of irrigation. He wanted the first colony to be called New Plymouth and wanted it located in southwestern Idaho in Payette Valley, which he had found apt for his purpose because of the extraordinary water supply from the nearby Payette River. The history of irrigation is still visible today, in the many original waterwheels that were built in the 1920’s. The city itself has a unique “horseshoe” shaped layout, with the open end facing North, the middle of which is home to a beautiful park and the main boulevard of the city. The community was at first called the New Plymouth Farm Village and was governed by a colony board of directors until it incorporated as a village in 1908, dropping the last two words in its name. New Plymouth was designated a city in 1948.

Tuttle Blacksmith and Welding
The original blacksmith shop was reported to be the first business in New Plymouth, owned and operated by Walter Burke who charged 25 cents for the first job. It was originally located on the cities main street, Plymouth Avenue, on the Van Patten Lumber site. The Tuttle Blacksmith shop carries the name of Ray Tuttle who came with his family in 1893 from Dunshore, Pennsylvania. While in the army he got his blacksmith training and he shod many horses and mules; deciding that this was the occupation he wanted to pursue. Today the Tuttle Blacksmith shop is still in business at its second location on Maple Street, where they provide a number of services all steeped in a fine history of quality and pride in workmanship.

Payette County Fair
New Plymouth is home to the annual Payette County Fair, held at the Payette County Fairgrounds. There’s a little something for everyone at the fair including 4-H and FFA shows, Free Music, Raffles, Games, Contest, Demonstrations, and of course lots of great food to enjoy while you are there. The fair is a great way to bring the community and surrounding towns together for a fun time for all ages.


Search All New Plymouth Properties

222 N Plymouth Ave Property Photo 1
Hunter of Homes, LLC Logo
Listing Provided By: Hunter of Homes, LLC
$8,000,000
222 N Plymouth Ave 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Square Feet67,809
  • $/SF$ 118
  • Built
  • Zoning
6258 Se 3rd Ave Property Photo 1
Silvercreek Realty Group Logo
Listing Provided By: Silvercreek Realty Group
$1,899,000
6258 SE 3rd Ave 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds4
  • Baths55
  • SqFt4,5124.5k
  • Built2024
4920 & 4940 Hwy 72 Property Photo 1
50
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Silverhawk Realty Logo
Listing Provided By: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Silverhawk Realty
$1,775,000
4920 & 4940 Hwy 72 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds3
  • Baths33
  • SqFt5,2135.2k
  • Built2007
4920 & 4940 Hwy 72 Property Photo 1
50
Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Silverhawk Realty Logo
Listing Provided By: Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Silverhawk Realty
$1,775,000
4920 & 4940 Hwy 72 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds3
  • Baths33
  • SqFt3,1933.2k
  • Built
Tbd Sand Hollow Rd Property Photo 1
Waldo Real Estate Logo
Listing Provided By: Waldo Real Estate
$1,729,000
TBD Sand Hollow Rd 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Lot Size91.00 Acres
  • $/acre$19,000
  • ZoningAgriculture
4523 Se 3rd Ave Property Photo 1
FLX Real Estate, LLC Logo
Listing Provided By: FLX Real Estate, LLC
$1,684,201
4523 SE 3rd Ave 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Lot Size42.00 Acres
  • $/acre$40,100
  • ZoningCommercial
3820 Dundee Dr. Property Photo 1
OPEN HOUSE 10/17
Real Broker LLC Logo
Listing Provided By: Real Broker LLC
$1,280,000
3820 Dundee Dr. 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds5
  • Baths33
  • SqFt4,4884.5k
  • Built2014
3942 Vista Ridge Ln Property Photo 1
Idaho Life Real Estate Logo
Listing Provided By: Idaho Life Real Estate
$1,140,000
3942 Vista Ridge Ln 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds3
  • Baths33
  • SqFt4,1434.1k
  • Built2013
4535 Se 3rd Ave Property Photo 1
Hunter of Homes, LLC Logo
Listing Provided By: Hunter of Homes, LLC
$899,900
4535 SE 3rd Ave 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds4
  • Baths44
  • SqFt3,8973.9k
  • Built2005
5367 Sand Hollow Road Property Photo 1
Gateway Realty Advisors Logo
Listing Provided By: Gateway Realty Advisors
$875,000
5367 Sand Hollow Road 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds4
  • Baths22
  • SqFt2,2442.2k
  • Built1929
5367 Sand Hollow Rd Property Photo 1
Gateway Realty Advisors Logo
Listing Provided By: Gateway Realty Advisors
$875,000
5367 Sand Hollow Rd 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds4
  • Baths22
  • SqFt1,8441.8k
  • Built
3902 Vista Ridge Ln Property Photo 1
Skyline Realty Logo
Listing Provided By: Skyline Realty
$875,000
3902 Vista Ridge Ln 
New Plymouth, ID 83655
  • Beds3
  • Baths22
  • SqFt2,2612.3k
  • Built2015
Real Estate Links Our Domains